Thanksgiving 2012: A Collective Amnesia

22 Nov

Last night we inadvertently caught about 5 minutes of the Charlie Brown Thanksgiving episode, just enough to hear Linus declare: “… We thank God for the opportunity to create the New World for freedom and justice.”  Irony much? What an extraordinarily white perspective that does not align with reality. Freedom and Justice for whom?

I often wonder, do we collectively, as Americans, conveniently choose to forget the genocide of the native peoples living in North America–the use of bio-warfare?  Yes, multi-generations of white folk have benefitted from the slaughtering of indigenous populations in North America and stealing land. It is ironic that the early survival of the Plymouth colony depended so heavily on the agricultural and fishing advice of the Wampanoag.

The whole idea of a “first Thanksgiving” is historically murky at best, with both religious and civil harvest festivals easily traceable to the Spanish in St. Augustine and British colonies in Jamestown and Plymouth. The native populations also had histories of harvest festivals, thus rendering a colonizer’s claim of “first” another in a series of misappropriations. Regular Thanksgiving celebrations as fixed civil events became common much later, dating to the 1660s.

As with so much of early colonial American history, most of what we “remember” is filtered through centuries of creative reconstruction: bucolic paintings, myths of noble savages and honest oppressed British outcasts, grade school songs and pageants. It is understandable that we prefer not to dwell on our collective responsibility for the decimation of whole populations, but it is an important part of our nation’s history. The colonizers’ relationship with the native populations was complex (and occassionally grateful) but seldom benefitted the natives and almost certainly did not involve everybody sharing a lovely meal around a table in peace.

Let us not forget this was no mere land grab but a decimation of Holocaust proportions. Our mistreatment of the indigenous peoples in North America went on well into the 20th Century with the Termination Act, Allotment, and the creation of Boarding Schools where white people thought their job was to “kill the Indian to save the man.”

The root idea of Thanksgiving — shared by the Europeans and the indigenous peoples — as a celebration is a good one. Be thankful for what you have; celebrate the cherished loved ones in your life; take time to remember what is good and bountiful with no expectations of gain other than shared love and thanks. Let us move forward as a nation, correctly learning, remembering, and growing from our history. Let us work hard to return to this spirit of Thanksgiving. It need not be buried in any trivia: upcoming shopping orgies (conspicuous consumption), 437 sporting events, overindulgence for its own sake, or cute “historical” imagery that overlooks a complex history.

We all have people and events in our lives worthy of celebration; that is what we should use today to be truly thankful for. I hope everyone reading this blog will be able to spend time with cherished loved ones, be it families of origin or families and communities we create.  TSM wishes everyone much peace and to be surrounded by love today.

10 Responses to “Thanksgiving 2012: A Collective Amnesia”

  1. Chris November 22, 2012 at 7:23 am #

    I guess a game of Cowboys and Indians would be ‘Not Appropriate’. Another lifetime ago it seems. Happy Thanksgiving Michael! *big Hugs!

    • Michael Hulshof-Schmidt November 22, 2012 at 7:57 am #

      Isn’t it amazing at how even our generation was so racist against our Native brothers and sisters. I hope you have a wonderful Turkey Day. Big hug, Michael.

  2. Central Oregon Coast NOW November 22, 2012 at 7:58 am #

    Wonderful blog today Michael! Happy Thanksgiving to your and Robert.

    • Michael Hulshof-Schmidt November 22, 2012 at 7:59 am #

      Thank you, Nancy! Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours. Much love, Michael

      • Tom McCollin November 22, 2012 at 9:07 am #

        Such a thought provoking and emotional article Michael. By the time I was finished reading this my eyes were teary. Despite how this holiday began, I have so much to be thankful for, not just today, but every one. He is the man that I love so so much. And also friends such as you, Happy Thanksgiving Michael!

      • Michael Hulshof-Schmidt November 22, 2012 at 10:06 am #

        Thank you for your kind comments! I hope you and Jamie have a wonderful Thanksgiving together!

  3. nevercontrary November 22, 2012 at 6:06 pm #

    Thank you for writing this, I so often think about this. Why is thanksgiving a holiday? Don’t even get me started on Christmas. Christ the center of a holiday that is pagan that they added him to in order to convince people to convert. I think I am little too hormonal this holiday season.

    • Michael Hulshof-Schmidt November 22, 2012 at 10:29 pm #

      Bonnie, I love your comments and your blog! Thank you for your comment here regarding my feelings about Thanksgiving.

  4. momshieb November 23, 2012 at 4:53 am #

    Great post today, thank you!
    While I love the traditions of Thanksgiving (I love being able to cook for a big group) and the chance to have my family around me and to tell them that I love them, I also struggle with the whole “Pilgrim” fable. I teach fifth grade in Massachusetts, and spent a long time with week gently correcting (I hope!) the imagery of the freedom seeking Pilgrims and the happy natives who welcomed them with popcorn. We reenacted what it might have felt like to live in a place for thousands of years and then have strangers suddenly show up and start cutting down trees. The kids came to the conclusion that it wouldn’t have felt good! We read some Wompanoag oral traditions and some primary source documents from that celebration; the kids realized it was a bit of a saber rattling exercise!

    • Michael Hulshof-Schmidt November 23, 2012 at 7:42 am #

      I think we should all be grateful/thankful for teachers like you that are helping students to see power as a dominant discourse by taking appropriate baby steps. I love what you are doing with your kids about a bunch of new folk just showing up one day and cutting down all the trees. Well done.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: